Paid My Dues opened Freak of Nature, Anastacia's second album, and was released as its first single in November 2001. The lyric answers critics who had treated her debut as a manufactured success, and the arrangement matches it — brass, live drums and a chorus pitched for the top of her range. It became a top-ten single across much of Europe and in Australia. The album as a whole moved away from the dance-pop production of Not That Kind towards the rock-soul mixture that stayed with her for the next two decades.